Part 3 of NEW IN TOWN
The Wrong Side of the Street

Two women. Two different worlds. One love their town refuses to understand.
The first thing Evelyn Carter noticed about the little Georgia town was the heat.
The second was the way people stared.
It was June 1962, and the temperature had already climbed past ninety degrees when her powder-blue Chevrolet pulled up outside a white wooden house on Magnolia Street.
Evelyn stepped out, straightened her fashionable yellow summer dress, and adjusted her sunglasses.
At thirty-four, she was an attractive, confident Black woman who had spent most of her adult life in Chicago. She had worked as a dress designer, saved her money, and built a respectable clientele.
Now her Aunt Josephine had left her a house in the South.
A fresh start, perhaps.
Across the white picket fence, a woman was tending her roses.
She was tall, blonde, perhaps thirty-eight, wearing a pale pink sleeveless dress and white sandals.
"Good morning," Evelyn called.
The woman looked up.
For a moment, she seemed surprised.
Then she smiled.
"Good morning. Are you moving in?"
"I am. Evelyn Carter."
"Margaret Collins. I live next door."
"Well, Margaret Collins, I hope you don't mind having a dressmaker for a neighbor."
Margaret laughed.
"Only if you make me something beautiful."
Evelyn smiled.
"That can certainly be arranged."
Neither woman knew how much that simple conversation would change their lives.
The trouble began three days later.
Evelyn had spent the morning unpacking and decided to have lunch at the café on Main Street.
She wore a beautifully tailored blue pencil skirt, a white blouse, matching heels, and pearl earrings.
The bell above the café door jingled.
Conversation stopped.
The proprietor, a heavyset man behind the counter, looked at her.
"What do you want?"
"A table for one, please."
He pointed toward the door.
"We don't serve colored folks in here."
Evelyn stood perfectly still.
"I see."
"You heard me, lady."
At a table near the window, Margaret Collins sat with two women from her church.
She recognized Evelyn immediately.
Their eyes met.
For one brief moment, Evelyn thought Margaret might say something.
But Margaret looked away.
Evelyn turned and walked out.
She didn't cry.
She was far too angry for that.
At four that afternoon, somebody knocked on Evelyn's front door.
Margaret stood on the porch holding a basket covered with a clean white napkin.
"Hello, Evelyn."
Evelyn folded her arms.
"Mrs. Collins."
Margaret winced.
"I brought you something. Biscuits, peach preserves, and some lemonade."
"How thoughtful."
The sarcasm was unmistakable.
Margaret looked down.
"About what happened at the café—"
"You were there."
"Yes."
"You watched that man humiliate me."
"I know."
"And you said nothing."
Margaret swallowed.
"I should have."
Evelyn glanced at the basket.
"And now you think a few biscuits will make everything better?"
"No."
Margaret raised her eyes.
"But I hoped they might give us somewhere to begin."
For a long moment, Evelyn studied her.
Then she stepped aside.
"Well, the lemonade had better be good."
Margaret smiled nervously.
"It's my grandmother's recipe."
"Then come inside, Margaret Collins. Let's see what your grandmother knew about lemonade."
The lemonade was excellent.
So were the biscuits.
And despite herself, Evelyn discovered that Margaret was rather delightful company.
Margaret was a widow. Her husband had died four years earlier, leaving her a small flower shop on Main Street and a house that suddenly felt much too large.
She had no children.
She had few close friends.
And she admitted, with some embarrassment, that she had never traveled farther north than Nashville.
"You should visit Chicago," Evelyn suggested.
"I wouldn't know what to do with myself."
"Darling, that's half the pleasure."
Margaret laughed.
It was a lovely laugh.
Evelyn noticed.
Margaret noticed Evelyn noticing.
And suddenly both women became interested in their lemonade.
Over the following two weeks, Margaret began visiting regularly.
At first, she brought flowers.
Then recipes.
Then nothing at all.
She simply appeared at Evelyn's back door, usually after closing the flower shop.
Evelyn showed her the dresses she was designing.
Margaret modeled them.
One afternoon, Evelyn handed her a fitted red cocktail dress.
"Try this."
Margaret stared.
"Good heavens! I couldn't possibly wear that."
"Why not?"
"It's far too daring."
"Nonsense. You're a beautiful woman, Margaret. You should dress like one."
Margaret disappeared into the bedroom.
When she returned, Evelyn stopped sewing.
The dress fitted perfectly.
Margaret turned nervously.
"Well?"
Evelyn smiled slowly.
"Good Lord."
"Is it terrible?"
"Quite the opposite."
Margaret blushed.
"Nobody's looked at me like that in years."
Evelyn stood and adjusted the dress at her shoulder.
"Then the gentlemen in this town must be blind."
Margaret looked at her.
"Perhaps I've been looking in the wrong direction."
Evelyn's hands became still.
For a moment, neither woman spoke.
Then Margaret laughed nervously and turned toward the mirror.
But Evelyn remembered those words.
The first kiss happened on a rainy Thursday afternoon.
Margaret had arrived soaked from a sudden thunderstorm.
Evelyn wrapped a towel around her shoulders and insisted she change into something dry.
An hour later, they were sitting on the sofa, drinking coffee while rain battered the windows.
Margaret wore one of Evelyn's soft cotton robes.
"You're spoiling me," she said.
"Someone should."
Margaret smiled.
Then her expression changed.
"Evelyn, may I ask you something personal?"
"That depends."
"Have you ever been in love?"
Evelyn considered the question.
"Yes."
"Were you married?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because the person I loved was a woman."
Margaret stared at her.
"Oh."
Evelyn watched her carefully.
"Does that shock you?"
Margaret shook her head.
"Not as much as it probably should."
Evelyn smiled.
"And you?"
Margaret looked down at her coffee.
"My husband was a good man. But I don't believe I ever loved him the way a wife is supposed to."
"Perhaps you simply hadn't met the right person."
Margaret raised her eyes.
"Perhaps."
The silence grew longer.
Outside, thunder rolled across the summer sky.
Margaret set down her cup.
"Evelyn?"
"Yes, darling?"
"Would it be terribly improper if I kissed you?"
Evelyn's heart began to race.
"Margaret Collins, I believe half this town would faint."
Margaret leaned closer.
"Then it's fortunate they're not here."
Their lips met.
The kiss was hesitant at first.
Then Margaret wrapped her arms around Evelyn and kissed her again.
When they finally separated, Margaret was breathless.
"Oh, my goodness."
Evelyn laughed softly.
"Was that all right?"
Margaret smiled.
"Could we do it again?"
They spent the rest of the afternoon together.
The rain continued, drumming softly against the windows, while two women who had spent years pretending to be satisfied with their lives discovered something neither had expected.
By the time the clouds broke, Margaret was resting against Evelyn beneath the bedroom covers.
"Evelyn?"
"Mmm?"
"I'm frightened."
Evelyn stroked her blonde hair.
"Of me?"
"Good heavens, no."
"Then what?"
Margaret looked toward the window.
"Of what people would say."
Evelyn sighed.
"People already have plenty to say about me, darling."
"It's different for you."
Evelyn gently lifted Margaret's chin.
"Yes. It is."
Margaret realized immediately what she'd said.
"I'm sorry."
Evelyn shook her head.
"You can walk into that café tomorrow and order lunch. I can't. You can hold a man's hand on Main Street without anybody giving you a second glance. I couldn't even sit beside you in certain places without attracting trouble."
Margaret's eyes filled with tears.
"I know."
"No, sweetheart. You're beginning to know."
Margaret leaned forward and kissed her.
"Then teach me."
Evelyn smiled sadly.
"I'd rather love you."
"Could we do both?"
Evelyn drew her close.
"I suppose we could try."
For three weeks, they were careful.
Margaret entered through Evelyn's back garden.
They shared afternoon meals, exchanged kisses behind closed curtains, and sometimes spent entire Sundays together.
Margaret had never been happier.
But happiness, she discovered, could be terribly fragile.
One Saturday morning, Mrs. Dorothy Wilkins entered Margaret's flower shop.
Dorothy was president of the church ladies' auxiliary and considered herself responsible for the moral health of the entire town.
"I hear you've been spending considerable time with that colored woman on Magnolia Street."
Margaret continued arranging roses.
"Her name is Evelyn Carter."
"I know perfectly well what her name is."
"Then you might use it."
Dorothy stiffened.
"Margaret Collins, people are beginning to talk."
"People always talk."
"You're a respectable white widow. What possible business could you have associating with someone like her?"
Margaret set down her scissors.
"She's my friend."
"Well, you had better reconsider that friendship. The ladies at church are very concerned."
"How unfortunate."
Dorothy stepped closer.
"If you continue visiting her, people may stop coming into this shop."
Margaret felt her stomach tighten.
The flower shop was her livelihood.
Her security.
Everything her husband had left her.
Then the bell above the door rang.
Evelyn stood in the entrance, wearing a stylish green dress and carrying a small parcel.
She had heard enough.
"I didn't mean to interrupt."
Dorothy turned.
Her expression hardened.
"Well, there she is."
Evelyn looked at Margaret.
For one awful moment, Margaret almost said nothing.
Just as she had in the café.
Then she remembered Evelyn's face that afternoon.
The humiliation.
The disappointment.
And the way Evelyn had still opened her door.
Margaret stepped out from behind the counter.
"Mrs. Wilkins, I think you should leave."
Dorothy stared.
"I beg your pardon?"
"You heard me."
"Margaret!"
"Evelyn Carter is my friend. She is welcome in this shop, in my home, and anywhere else I choose to invite her."
Dorothy's mouth fell open.
"You will regret this."
"Perhaps."
Margaret opened the door.
"But I would regret being ashamed of a good woman far more."
Dorothy marched out.
The bell jingled furiously behind her.
For a moment, the shop was silent.
Evelyn looked at Margaret.
"That took courage."
Margaret's hands were shaking.
"I thought I was going to faint."
Evelyn smiled.
"You didn't."
"No."
Margaret walked toward her.
"I should have done that at the café."
"Yes," Evelyn said quietly. "You should have."
Margaret nodded.
"Will you forgive me?"
Evelyn took her hand.
"I already have."
Margaret glanced toward the shop window.
People were passing outside.
A few were staring.
She gently squeezed Evelyn's fingers.
"I love you."
Evelyn's expression softened.
"Margaret..."
"I know this town won't understand. I know we'll have to be careful. But I'm tired of being frightened of everybody."
Evelyn stepped closer.
"Are you certain?"
Margaret smiled through her tears.
"More certain than I've ever been about anything."
Evelyn kissed her cheek.
"I love you too, darling."
The consequences came quickly.
Several regular customers stopped ordering flowers.
A church committee canceled its arrangements for the summer social.
Someone painted an ugly message on Evelyn's front fence.
Margaret was furious.
Evelyn was not surprised.
But they were not entirely alone.
A young schoolteacher began ordering flowers from Margaret.
A Black church across town commissioned Evelyn to make choir robes.
And a few neighbors, quietly and without making speeches, continued doing business with both women.
One evening, Margaret sat beside Evelyn on the back porch, watching fireflies dance above the garden.
"I've been thinking," Margaret said.
"That sounds dangerous."
Margaret laughed.
"About the shop."
"What about it?"
"I have an empty room upstairs. You could use it for sewing."
Evelyn turned.
"Above your flower shop?"
"Why not?"
"Margaret, your customers—"
"My customers will simply have to get used to the idea that I have a business partner."
Evelyn studied her.
"You realize it could make things harder?"
"Yes."
"Much harder."
Margaret took her hand.
"I realize something else, too."
"What's that?"
"Ever since you arrived, I've been happier than at any time I can remember."
Evelyn smiled.
"Even with all this trouble?"
"Especially now. At least I'm finally living my own life."
Evelyn leaned over and kissed her.
They sat together as the evening grew dark.
Two women in a small Southern town.
One Black.
One white.
Neither entirely safe from the prejudices surrounding them.
But both determined to build something together.
Six months later, a new sign appeared above Margaret's flower shop.
COLLINS & CARTER
Flowers, Fashions & Fine Dressmaking
Some townspeople still refused to enter.
Others became regular customers.
And every evening, when the shop closed, Margaret and Evelyn drove home together in Evelyn's powder-blue Chevrolet.
They still had to choose carefully where they went and whom they trusted.
The world outside their front door had not suddenly become kind.
But inside their home, there was laughter, music, affection, and two coffee cups waiting on the kitchen table every morning.
One Sunday afternoon, Margaret stood before the bedroom mirror wearing the red cocktail dress Evelyn had made for her.
"Do you think it's too daring?"
Evelyn looked up from the bed.
"Darling, I've told you a hundred times. It's perfect."
Margaret turned around.
"Are you sure?"
Evelyn held out her arms.
"Come here and let me inspect it properly."
Margaret laughed and hurried toward her.
And somewhere beyond their little house, the rest of the town continued arguing about who belonged where.
Inside, however, the two women had already decided.
They belonged together.
THE END
NEW IN TOWN — Stories of unexpected arrivals, forbidden affection, and women who discover that love sometimes begins with the person living next door.
Historical fiction: The characters and events are fictional. The story is set against the real history of racial segregation and discrimination in the American South during the early 1960s.
Writing one? Publish your story on the BudgetPixel blog.