Start creating free

Watercolor

@antares@antares··3 min read·12 comments
Watercolor

I have always liked watercolor painting. I greatly admire those artists who – especially in the nineteenth century – mastered the technique of skillfully balancing color intensity and the application of glazes, achieving stunning results with their confident brushstrokes. Unfortunately, I must confess that I have never quite lived up to those masters, even though I do manage to produce something decent now and then. Unlike other painting techniques, such as oil or acrylic, watercolor is unforgiving, and mistakes cannot be corrected. One of the most famous watercolorists, whose works I have always admired, was Ettore Roesler Franz (1845-1907): he captured many scenes of 19th-century Rome "on the spot," before they were lost forever in the mists of the past. Here is an example of his skill as a painter of cityscapes: around 140 of his watercolors can be seen today in a permanent exhibition at the Museum of Rome, not far from Piazza Navona.

Illustration: Watercolor

For these reasons, I wanted to experiment with AI to see which models were best suited to capturing not only the effects but the very spirit of watercolor painting. I began my research by deriving a prompt from an old photograph to use for text-to-image generation, ensuring the model would not be influenced by a pre-existing reference image. Here is the prompt I used:

"Watercolor illustration on white textured paper; edges slightly faded. An elderly man with white hair and a beard, wearing a brown leather jacket with a shearling collar, stands motionless at the edge of an old stone-and-wood canal lock. He gazes down into the still water. Canal water: opaque depths, distorted and faded reflections of the wooden gates, translucent patches of bluish-grey and ochre, faint ripples, no specular highlights, and color gradients blending without hard edges. Style: traditional watercolor; fine, light black ink lines for outlines only; soft shading; visible paper texture with slight grain; desaturated palette of earth tones and greys; flat, twilight atmosphere; no digital effects. Composition viewed slightly from above; low horizon line; pale, empty sky."

Below, I will briefly comment only on the most interesting results obtained with the various models tested.

Illustration: Watercolor

Above, SeeDream 5: the watercolor effect is rather good, but the image is poor and the textured paper effect is not sufficiently emphasized.

Illustration: Watercolor

GPT Image 2.5 (quality: High) is much better; the paper grain is clearly visible, and the landscape has been completed in a way that is consistent with the subject's atmosphere.

Illustration: Watercolor

Here is the result for GPT Image 2.5, Medium quality (cheaper), without changing anything in the prompt. In my opinion, we are at the same level as the previous image.

Illustration: Watercolor

This is the result with Qwen 3.0 Pro: the edge of the paper is clearly visible and the watercolor effect is satisfactory, but the image is – once again – poor in quality.

Illustration: Watercolor

With Grok Imagine 2.0 (Medium quality), we are more or less on the same level, although the image turns out more complete.

Illustration: Watercolor

This is the same model, Grok Imagine 2.0 (Low quality): the paper grain is reproduced very faithfully. Other models, such as Muse, Nano Banana 2 or Ideogram, gave very poor results, which are not worth showing here.

Perhaps the best watercolor effects were obtained wit Gpt-Image-2 (Medium quality). Here they are:

Illustration: WatercolorIllustration: Watercolor

In conclusion, if you love watercolors, you can achieve excellent results with GPT-Image-2 (Low or Medium quality) by using a suitable prompt and, optionally, an old black-and-white photo as a reference image. Here are some examples of the effects that can be achieved. If you have a good color printer, some of them could be worth printing!

Illustration: WatercolorIllustration: WatercolorIllustration: Watercolor

Comments (12)

  • @crabmouse·

    Great! Not surprising that GPT is the best. I wonder if any image generator will surpass them. ps I have a cat blog up! I just need 20 more claps to get to 500!

  • @crabmouse·

    Gave claps! Please respond to this comment so I remember to read it when I get home!

  • @panos·

    Great blog on the cmparison of the different models. Watercolor is a lovely style.

  • @CaylaCatz·

    Very cool! I love seeing different models doing the same style

  • @antares·

    Thank you! Actually, I only use only Gpt-Image-2 for watercolors now 😎

Sign in to read all 12 comments and add yours.

More from @antares

All posts →
Samantha's Vacation

Samantha's Vacation

Samantha clicked her heels along the rain-slicked park path, the evening chill biting sharply against her exposed skin. She drew in a deep, slow breath, letting the…

@crabmouse@crabmouse··37 min read
Somewhere far far away ... Part 6

Somewhere far far away ... Part 6

by CaylaCatz and @panos Chapter 12 images and text by panos The Wizard's chapter: My teeth clenched even further, the engine-room begun to be lighted by flickers of…

@CaylaCatz@CaylaCatz··7 min read
"Guess the word" game

"Guess the word" game

I was writing a comment and remembered this puzzle game. The object is to reflect a word in an image, no letters involved. Here is my first puzzle to get the ball…

@DavidP@DavidP··2 min read
The Wrong Side of the Street

The Wrong Side of the Street

Two women. Two different worlds. One love their town refuses to understand. The first thing Evelyn Carter noticed about the little Georgia town was the heat. The second…

@germancowboy@germancowboy··10 min read
STORIES to Keep you AWAKE

STORIES to Keep you AWAKE

The storm arrived before nightfall. From the harbor of Blackwater, the sky looked like an iron vault descending over the sea. The clouds had swallowed the last light in…

@charlypalermo@charlypalermo··13 min read

← All posts on the BudgetPixel blog