Whodunit police lineup puzzle asking viewers to identify the lying…

By @crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026

9 likes · 22 comments

Halp! Who done did it?

Entry in the Fantasy Criminals and Syndicates theme.

About this image

This playful deduction puzzle features a humorous police mugshot lineup of female suspects, each sharing a statement to help solve who stole a cookie. The graphic uses a neutral booking wall background, bold top prompt text, and speech bubbles to guide players to find the liar. The lighthearted brain teaser uses bright red accents from suspect shirts and clear character labeling to make the riddle easy to follow.

Comments (22)

@EternaSky · Nov 14, 2026
I lean to Jessica but that scarf doesnt look like a shirt... or is scarf a shirt....
@panos · Nov 14, 2026
BESIDES Bell - a fairy stole LOTS of cookies!! The Bard has video evidence of it!!! 🙂
@crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026
So it would mean she's not lying and not the thief!
@crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026
Bell would be telling the truth about repeating letters!
@crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026
You should delete this one so other people can try!
@crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026
That would make Aimee a liar too same with Kelly.
@JMN · Nov 14, 2026
I was looking for one with fairy wings, panos.😂
@EternaSky · Nov 14, 2026
does officer count as #1 or is Amanda #1?
@EternaSky · Nov 14, 2026
the twist... it's Officer Vanessa
@crabmouse · Nov 14, 2026
That would make Angelique a liar!