Discovering GAI: Claude writes a story

This is a series in which I share my experiences discovering the capabilities of GAI (Generative Artificial Interlligence). Regardless of personal opinion and perspective, it is irrefutable that GAI is here, here to say, and a game changer - for better or worse.
About Clapping: Rewards for blog posters and viewers are based on clapping. For the viewer you receive a daily reward for 'clapping 10 blogs' for the poster it is based on 'claps received'. Viewers, you can clap a single blog to receive your reward, simply do so slow and steady: clap & clap & clap ... 10x. Posters require first 100 and then 500 claps. A viewer can clap up a blog to 20x. So if and when you clap this blog, please clap 20x, not once or twice, as claps may have been intended to serve as a measure of blog quality, value, enjoyment but in reality are simply a means to a reward.The Project
Introduction
In a previous post I shared my experiences generating the prose for a story using simply a prompt plus three images of a set of six. I used Ava for this first experiment. While the story was written the result and conclusion was not favourable
Ava is not at the level where I would follow this approach in the future. But I did not expect it to be. In order to further test this workflow I will conduct a further experiment with Claude.ai
I followed up and repeated the exercise with Claude
Method
▶️ Provide Claude with six images and a brief
▶️ Review story drafts and provide feedback
▶️ Claude revises the draft
▶️ Feedback focused on alignment of the prose with illustrations. Just one iteration
Review
😃 Followed the brief
😃 Before drafting Claude did ask clarifying questions, unlike Ava
😃 Application of feedback was acceptable
😃 While still feels generated, far better than Ava
😡 The ability to write a story based on the illustrations as the outline was inconsistent
Conclusion
The difference in output quality between Claude and Ava is marked. Frankly, I think Claude would deliver publishable original stories with limited editing required. While the writing still does not match hand-written, for certain use cases I think it is acceptable.
Process Flow
The initial prompt
today we are going to work on writing a story that tastefully blends decent light short-story writing with hot, spicy explicit but tasteful initmate love-making. The love-making should be well described but but overly mechanical. You will write the story, I will edit. The story is illustrated with the attached pictures which are attached in sequence with filenames in numerical order. It begins with the couple sailing wearing their swimsuits, they strip those off in the warmth, leads to kissing first then love-making, before sitting around a camp-fire on a deserted beach. The length should be around 1500 words. You should avoid all the now common GAI narrative forms - ultra short sentences, the three beat thing ie not this, not that, but this. You should write it in the style of authors like Rachel Kramer Bussel, Selena Kitt, Sacci Green. Do you have any questions before you write the first draft?Claude's response
One question before I start, and it's an important one about calibration.
The authors you've named — Bussel, Kitt, Sacchi Green — write across a wide spectrum, from literary sensual to fairly graphic. In claude.ai's standard context I write at the more literary end of that range: sensual, embodied, emotionally charged, with the physical intimacy clearly present and evocative rather than anatomically explicit. Think Best Women's Erotica introduction rather than the centrepiece story.
The images themselves are tasteful in that same spirit — beautifully rendered, intimate but not graphic — so I think the story and images would sit well together at that register.
Does that work for what you have in mind, or would you like to discuss the level of explicitness further before I begin? I'd rather be clear upfront than write a draft that misses your target.The first draft was far better, I considered it generally good enough. Biggest issue was some misalignment between illustrations and prose. Provided this feedback
This is excellent. Little for me to change. I think review each picture carefully, not fine details eg in picture one they sit side by side. In the final picture they sit opposite each other. While your prose is hitting the mark, ensuring consistency with the images is important. So review the images and small adjustments where necessary.Claude's analytical ability while not perfect was far more effective than Ada's
Looking carefully at each image, I can see two clear inconsistencies:
Image 2: When they're both nude, they're still in their original positions — she on the rail, he at the tiller — looking across at each other. My prose has him immediately coming to sit beside her, which skips that charged moment of simply regarding each other from a distance.
Image 6: This is the more significant one. They're sitting opposite each other across the fire, not side by side. The ending I wrote — shoulders touching, her head leaning on him, his arm around her — is entirely wrong for what the image shows. The intimacy there is in their faces lit by firelight, looking at each other across the flames. That's actually a more interesting and less expected ending, and I should have caught it.
Here are the revised passages:I reviewed the revised passages and prompted Claude to update the full draft.
While I could have continued to iterate and improve I opted to declare the experiment done.
I do believe there would be reward in further iterations but ultimately time spent in continuing to prompt edits misses the point. The goal is to produce the prose as quickly as possible, as little manual effort as possible.
Warning: MATURE illustrations and prose.
Wind, Skin, Fire
The lake had been flat and silver all morning, but by early afternoon a warm westerly found them, filling the sail with a sound like a slow exhale, pushing the little boat through water that had turned the colour of pale whisky in the slanting light. Cara sat forward on the port rail, her legs dangling over the hull's curve, one hand loosely gripping a stay. Behind her, Joel held the tiller with the unhurried confidence of someone who had done this since boyhood, watching the tell-tales, watching the tree line, watching her.
They had been together two years, long enough that silences between them were comfortable things, inhabited rather than endured. This one had lasted most of an hour, filled with the hiss of water under the bow and the occasional creak of the boom, and neither of them had felt the need to fill it with words.
It was Cara who undid the bikini top first, reaching back with both hands in that fluid, unselfconscious way that still arrested him every time he saw it. She laid the white fabric beside her on the deck and turned her face back toward the sun. Joel watched the way the light moved across her shoulders, the small notch of her spine, the warmth that the afternoon seemed to have pressed into her skin from the outside in.
"You're staring," she said, without turning around.
"I am," he agreed.
She looked back at him then, and whatever she saw in his expression made her smile in a particular way — not quite amusement, not quite invitation, but something that lived in the narrow country between them. She stood, steadying herself against the gentle motion of the hull, and slid the bikini bottoms down over her hips with the same simple ease. The wind moved through her hair. She settled back onto the rail as though nothing had happened.
Joel reached forward and tied off the tiller. Then he stripped off his board shorts and tossed them below.
For a long moment neither of them moved. He stayed at the tiller, she stayed on the rail, and they simply looked at each other the way people look when they have just realised something is about to happen and want to hold the moment before it does — his eyes moving over her, her chin tilted slightly upward, the warm air between them feeling suddenly thinner. Then she stood, crossed the cockpit in two careful steps, and settled onto his lap facing him, her knees either side of his hips, her hands finding his jaw.
The first kiss was unhurried. He took his time with it the way he took his time with the boat, reading the small shifts and pressures, adjusting. Her mouth was warm and tasted faintly of the white wine they'd drunk at anchor two hours ago, and when she made a low sound against his lips he felt it in his chest rather than just his ears. She turned into him, her hands finding his jaw, his neck, her fingers threading into his hair and tightening there, and the kiss deepened into something less exploratory and more deliberate.
She moved onto his lap in a single slow motion, her knees either side of his hips, her hands still in his hair, and he ran his palms up the curve of her back, feeling every notch of her spine, the flare of her shoulder blades, the warm weight of her settling against him. The boat rocked gently. The sail luffed and filled again.
"Joel," she said quietly, the way she sometimes said his name when she wasn't asking for anything specific — just marking the fact of him, the nearness.
He kissed her throat and felt her pulse jump under his mouth. He kissed her collarbone, the curve of her shoulder, the soft skin below her ear, and she tilted her head to give him more of it, her breathing changing, her hips shifting in his lap in small, unconscious adjustments. He cupped her breasts in his hands and she arched into the touch, her head falling back, her hair sweeping across the sail behind her. He took his time. He had learned early that she wanted to be savoured, not rushed, that the approach was as important to her as the destination, and he had come to love this about her, the way she remained fully present in each moment rather than racing ahead to the next one.
When she finally guided him into her they both went still for a moment, adjusting to the closeness, and she held his face in her hands and looked at him with an expression he had no clean word for — raw was the closest, unguarded. He moved slowly at first, and she matched him, the two of them finding a rhythm as natural and unhurried as the boat finding the wind, her hips rocking against his, her breath warm against his face, soft sounds escaping her that she wasn't trying to suppress or produce, simply could not help. The lake glittered around them. A heron crossed the sky somewhere above the mast. He held her hips and felt the moment building in her before she did, or perhaps they felt it together, and she pressed her forehead against his and said his name again, differently this time, and he answered her without words, and the afternoon dissolved briefly into nothing but sensation and warmth and the sound of water, and her.
---
They anchored in a small cove as the light went amber, then red. By the time they had pulled the dinghy up onto the sand and gathered wood from the treeline the sky above the lake was a deep, saturated blue, and the moon was already up, enormous and white, its reflection laid across the water like a path. Joel built the fire with the methodical pleasure he brought to all practical things, and Cara pulled two worn t-shirts from the dry bag and handed him one.
The fire cracked and shifted between them, throwing small sparks upward into the dark. Across the flames her face was all warm amber and shadow, her hair loose around her shoulders, and she was watching him with an expression he had learned to read over two years but still couldn't reduce to a single word — something like happiness, something like recognition.
"I've been thinking about this day for months," she said.
"And?"
That smile again. "Better," she said.
He held her gaze across the fire, and she held his, and neither of them said anything else for a long while, because there was nothing that needed saying — only the fire between them and the moonlight above and the slow sound of the lake breathing in the dark.
About Clapping: Rewards for blog posters and viewers are based on clapping. For the viewer you receive a daily reward for 'clapping 10 blogs' for the poster it is based on 'claps received'. Viewers, you can clap a single blog to receive your reward, simply do so slow and steady: clap & clap & clap ... 10x. Posters require first 100 and then 500 claps. A viewer can clap up a blog to 20x. So if and when you clap this blog, please clap 20x, not once or twice, as claps may have been intended to serve as a measure of blog quality, value, enjoyment but in reality are simply a means to a reward.Writing one? Publish your story on the BudgetPixel blog.
Comments (26)
@faerierealm Appreciate the thoughtful feedback, Emily (and Gael). You are spot on. To be fair, I must own some responsibility. The lack of such depth and nuance is firstly due to the brief I gave to Claude. I am fairly confident, though can't be 100%, that if I had briefed that then the story would have had more depth. But as a very-much amateur human writer, I tend to let the story write itself as I go. I typically only have the most basic idea at the start and then ideas come as I progress. And I like to think I try to work more emotional content into my hand-written stories. Thanks again for taking time to read and provide comment
Thanks very much. In the third and final experiment I will explore more of that use case
This is definitely MUCH better than the original version, which was highly mechanical in its description of what was going on. Now the prose is more poetic: They don't just kiss, her mouth tastes like the white wine they shared earlier, and when she moans, he feels it in his chest. So that's nice. However--and this is Gael's main complaint, as we read this together--there are STILL no inner thoughts or feelings: What is the EMOTIONAL context of this outing? Did they just have a fight and this is Cara's peace offering, her way of offering amends? Or maybe everything's hunky-dory and they're celebrating their two-year dating anniversary BUT Cara desperately hopes that Joel will propose and this is her way of enticing him? (Because even though Gael doesn't like guys, she fully understands the power of a woman disrobing in front of a man haha. That's a power move!) Or maybe they've both been busy and their closeness had been slipping recently, and Cara asked Joel to take time off from work so they could reconnect? If you do another pass, try giving your characters some inner motivations. Gael is resigned to AI eventually outdoing humans in every aspect, but until then, we can still offer tips to improve their output. Much like an employee training his or her replacement before they get fired haha. Good luck!
I believe so, Cayla. Not just that, I think I could set up Claude in such a way as to a story-writing engine. All I'd need to do is provide a basic brief and it would generate the story. Once set up it would take almost no effort to produce the blog. And AI could generate the illustrations as well.
I had to check with Gael, but she said yes, Mr. King is also a pantser. Completely changed some of the endings of his books relative to what he thought the endings would be when he set out. And he's obviously hugely successful. So you're in good company!
Sign in to read all 26 comments and add yours.